StatementAnalysisJodi

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, 8 February 2013

Statement Analysis: 17 Year Old Throws 9 Year Old Off Roof

Posted on 06:24 by Unknown




This is a horrific story in which a 17 year old is accused of throwing a 9 year old boy off the roof of a building. 

From the NY Daily News:


The twisted teen accused of throwing his 9-year-old neighbor off the roof of their Bronx building has

 been indicted for his attempted murder, prosecutors said.

Casmine Aska, 17, was also indicted on two counts of assault for the sickening Feb. 1 attack on Freddy

 Martin.

Freddy plunged five stories to the ground, and is in a medically induced coma on life support. He

 identified Aska as his attacker to the paramedics who rushed him to the hospital.



“Cas dragged me to the roof and threw me off — I don’t know why,” he said, according to court

 papers.

Note the direct language:  "Cas...threw me off"



Prosecutors said Aska dragged the boy by his legs up a flight of stairs before throwing him off the

 Morris Heights building.

Aska’s lawyer, Katherine Dyer, called the fall a “tragic accident.”

Is it?  The words will guide us. 

Her client’s been ordered held without bail pending his March 6 arraignment.




Here is the quote from the 17 year old for analysis.  The victim's statement is plain.


 "On the roof I grabbed Freddy around the legs. His feet were off the ground. I turned around. 

I slipped and Freddy fell. 

I did not call 911. I did not tell my mother. I did not check to see if Freddy was ok. I did not hear the thud until I went into the apartment" 


1.  "On the roof" is extra language which tells us that the subject may have grabbed the victim somewhere other than just the roof.  
2.  "I grabbed Freddy around the legs" is very straight forward and likely reliable. 
3.  "His feet were off the ground" is passive language.  His feet cannot go off the ground on its own.  The passivity shows attempt to conceal responsibility.  
4.  "Freddy fell" is also passive language.  He does not tell us how Freddy fell.  This is another attempt to remove himself from the responsibility. 
5.  Note all that he reports in the negative as very important:

a.  He did not call 911
b.  He did not tell his mother
c.  He did not check to see if Freddy was ok

d.  He did not "hear the thud" "until" he went into the apartment.  The deception here is obvious.

There is enough evidence in his statement to conclude that he deliberately threw the 9 year old off the roof in order to cause harm or death, and his report of what he did not do indicate not only that he wanted his victim to suffer/die (not receive help) but that he did not want his activities to be discovered. 


Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Texas Death Penalty Information
    http://myfox8.com/2013/04/27/ texas-inmate-shouts-wow- during-execution/ =================== 10 Women are on Death Row - including - DARLIE ...
  • Statement Analysis: Regional Understanding
    not exactly stamp collecting   Some have asked about what regionalism (culture) does to analysis, and it is something we not only recognize,...
  • Statement Analysis: Passivity in Sex Abuse Victims
                                                                                      Passivity in Sex Abuse Victims                           ...
  • Hailey Dunn Case: Statement Analysis 101
    The following is an introduction to Statement Analysis as used in the Hailey Dunn case, for new readers. The words come from the very first ...
  • Jhessye Shockley: Family Seeks Millions
    This is another "missing" child case we covered in which the mother was found deceptive in her statements about what happened to J...
  • Delay In Identifying Remains
    Front and Center                                                              What if the remains are Hailey's? If you were a prosecutor...
  • Hailey Dunn Case: An Inquisitive Grand Jury Part One
    Statement Analysis will not convict anyone of anything. There will be no "Billie Dunn dropped her pronoun right here!  Shawn Adkins iss...
  • Account of Jonbenet Ramsey Indictment
    What do you think Alex Hunter told himself when he set forth to deceive the public about the Grand Jury's indictment of John and Patsy R...
  • Day 7 Of Boy Hostage
    A close-knit Alabama community has blanketed their town with fliers imploring people to pray for a boy held hostage for almost seven days, a...
  • Statement Analysis: Zumba Prostitute Husband Analyzed
    When a school teacher notices that a little boy, who, being defined as a noisy ball of dirt, suddenly is washing his hands repeatedly, she o...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  August (34)
    • ►  July (23)
    • ►  June (47)
    • ►  May (64)
    • ►  April (98)
    • ►  March (90)
    • ▼  February (98)
      • Kaaryn Gough: Mark Redwine
      • Mark Redwine : "We're Going To Take Polygraph"
      • Will Jodi Get Away With Murder?
      • What Happened to Dylan Redwine
      • Dylan Redwine: Scent Hit
      • Statement Analysis: Barak Obama on Humility
      • "Absolutely Not. It is not" Miss Deleware
      • Eleven False Rape Allegations From Same Woman
      • Mark Redwine Killed Dylan Redwine
      • Dylan Redwine: Shocking Statements on Dr. Phil
      • Dylan Redwine Case on Dr. Phil Today
      • Another "Parent of the Year" Candidate?
      • Te'O Deception Leads NFL to Question
      • Orlando, Casey Anthony and David Wright
      • Acid Attack Arrests
      • Passivity in Acid Attack
      • Poll: Ryan Ferguson Interrogation Video
      • Texas Mom: Boy From Russia Outside Before Death
      • Ryan Ferguson on 48 Hours Tonight
      • Bus Driver Gets 160 Years in Autistic Rapes
      • Statement Analysis: Molestation Interview
      • Memory Loss and Deception
      • FBI Agents Dating Drug Dealers?
      • Learning From Kaaryn Gough
      • The Face of Evil: Shaniya's Killer
      • Blade Runner Attorney: No Forensic Evidence
      • Statement Analysis: Jodi Arias: Memory Issues
      • Shaniya Davis Killer Writes Letters
      • Oscar Pistorius Statement Analysis by Kaaryn Gough
      • Liars' Contempt Highlighted
      • Pistorius: Neighbor Heard Non Stop Shouting
      • Morgan Harrington Letter from Lt. Joe Rader
      • Statement Analysis of Justin DiPietro
      • Oscar Pistorius Affidavit Analyzed
      • Blade Runner: Premeditated Murder
      • Baby Ayla: Supporters' Base Behavior Revealed
      • Statement Analysis: Deborah Bradley Press Conference
      • Statement Analysis: Deborah Bradley
      • Baby Lisa Case Revisited
      • Morgan Harrington Case: Crime Wire 7PM EST Tuesda...
      • Hailey Dunn's Mother: A Picture's Worth A Thousan...
      • Ayla Reynolds: Life Insurance Motive Examined
      • Witchcraft and Violence in Tanzania
      • Blade Runner Murder Update
      • Dawn Drexel's Letter
      • Disappearance of Brittanee Drexel
      • Baby Ayla Q & A
      • The Account of Ayla Reynolds Analyzed
      • Michael Le Vell Statement Analysis
      • The "Animosity" Between Dylan Redwine's Parents
      • Statement Analysis: Phoebe DiPietro
      • Carol Bengle Gilbert on Ayla Reynolds
      • Deceptive 911 Calls
      • Anthony Ronzio Statement Analysis
      • Analyst Kaaryn Gough on Baby Ayla Case
      • Mark Redwine: Statement Analysis and Distance
      • Susan Cox' Brother-in-Law Commits Suicide
      • Statement Analysis: Matt Cooke
      • Barry Bonds Statement Analyzed
      • Dylan Redwine's Parents to Appear On Dr. Phil
      • Analysis: Drug-Dealing Fireman Case
      • District Attorney Refuses to Sign Indictment
      • Amanda Knox to Give Interview April 30th, 2013
      • Jodi Arias Testifies in Court
      • Mark Redwine: Lake And Dam by Kaaryn Gough
      • Mark Redwine: Statement Analysis by Kaaryn Gough ...
      • Elaine Redwine's Statement on Mark Redwine
      • Cop Accused of Groping Cuffed Pregnant Woman
      • Dylan Redwine: Crime Wire
      • Statement Analysis: Mark Redwine Deceptive
      • 1977 Murder Case: Solved
      • Statement Analysis: Mark Redwine
      • Confidence in Statement Analysis?
      • Statement Analysis: 17 Year Old Throws 9 Year Old...
      • Dylan Redwine's 14th Birthday Marked
      • FBI: Menendez Investigation Underaged Prostitutes
      • Ryan Braun: Steroids....Again? Statement Analysis
      • Muslim Cleric Fined for Rape and Murder of His 5 Y...
      • Lance Armstrong: Under Federal Investigation
      • Jim Bakker Statement Analysis
      • Steve Thomas' Letter
      • Crime Wire Tonight: JonBenet Ramsey Conclusion
      • "Sea Hag" Pleads Guilty
      • Bob Menendez Statement Analysis: Right Wing Smears
      • Jodi Arias Testifies In Court
      • 5 Year Old Boy Freed
      • Day 7 Of Boy Hostage
      • The Free Editing Process: Ramsey Press Conference
      • Statement For Analysis
      • Boy Hostage: Day Five
      • Understanding the Jonbenet Ramsey Case
      • Mother of the Year in Atlanta
      • Prisoner Of War Statement Analysis
      • Statement Analysis of Merry Pease Murder
      • Dylan Redwine's Father's Denial
      • Husband on Missing Wife Speaks Out
      • Statement Analysis: Jason London
      • 5 Year Old Boy Still Held Hostage
    • ►  January (46)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile